|

What Type of Landlord Are You? (A Property Manager’s Honest Take)

This is a slightly cheeky article that property managers everywhere have always thought but rarely say out loud. We are saying it out loud – because if you are aware of how you show up as a landlord, you can foster a better relationship with your property manager and get materially better service.

Wear whichever description fits you. The goal is not to shame anyone – it is to invite a moment of honest self-reflection that almost always leads to a better partnership.

Class A Landlord

The dream client. We work harder for these owners not because we have to, but because the partnership is genuinely enjoyable.

  • Hires a property manager and is glad to pay our fees, understanding we provide a real service that helps the asset grow.
  • Appreciates our systems, procedures, tools, and the layer of separation we provide between the owner and the tenant – recognizing the property manager is often the punching bag from both sides for years on end.
  • Allows us flexibility to make tough on-the-fly calls – like spending $505 on an A/C repair in 110-degree July when the threshold is $500 – without making it a federal case.
  • Understands that the property manager is not personally responsible for the weather or the marketplace.
  • Easy to reach. Responds to phone calls, emails, and texts.
  • Realizes paying us $20/hour effectively (in fees) frees them up to make $200/hour pursuing bigger deals or other investments.
  • Often a full-time or seasoned investor with capital reserves who fundamentally understands that management fees are far outweighed by appreciation, depreciation, and tax advantages.

Class B Landlord

Decent partnership. Some friction around money. We do good work for these owners and they generally appreciate it – they just second-guess everything that costs money.

  • Reluctantly hired a property manager after first shopping for the cheapest one they could find.
  • Second-guesses every repair item and laments not having reserves for larger repairs.
  • Often a “reluctant landlord” – never planned on owning a rental, became one through relocation, divorce, or inheritance.
  • Asks for two bids on every job to save $20 – even when it means the tenant is without A/C or hot water for several days while bids come in.
  • Does not understand basic accounting; needs constant explanation of the income/expense statement.
  • Slow to respond to urgent matters. Often unreachable for hours or days when a decision is needed.

Class C Landlord

Honest truth: we do not do C-tier owners well, and most experienced property managers eventually fire C-tier clients. The relationship is exhausting and the fees do not cover the cost of managing the owner (separate from managing the property).

  • Hired a property manager grudgingly because their CPA told them to.
  • Shops aggressively for the cheapest property manager – then asks for a discount on top because they are an “investor” (with two homes).
  • Is abusive to property management staff. Demands constant communication. Adopts the “Do you know who I am?” tone.
  • Introduces themselves to the tenant behind the property manager’s back, telling the tenant to call them anytime if the manager does not jump fast enough. This creates a Mommy/Daddy dynamic where the tenant runs around the property manager and management quality nosedives.
  • Demands three bids on every repair – no matter the inconvenience to the tenant or the cost of the time – to save $5.

Why This Article Exists

Honestly? Because almost everyone has B-class moments and almost no one is consistently A-class. That is fine. We work with humans, not idealizations. The point is: if you can recognize when you are slipping into B or C behavior, you can shift back, and the result is genuinely better service for you and a more enjoyable working relationship for both of us.

The single biggest move you can make to be an A-class owner: respond to us within one business day on time-sensitive items, and trust our judgment on the small stuff. Those two habits alone vault most owners into the top tier. We will work harder for you, faster, and with better humor – and your asset will perform better as a result.

Article in good fun. We love all our clients. Mostly.

Have questions about your rental?

Book a free 15-minute consult with our Florida team – no pressure, just answers.

Schedule Now

Similar Posts